I was asked by Rob Northrup what I thought about the issue of socialization with regards to Pre-K and homeschooling etc. Hmmmm… ok, here it is – my opinion…
Let me start with my personal experience. When my daughter was born I started a daycare in my home so that I could earn money but still be with my baby. I thought this was the perfect set up. However, I didn’t really research it well and so I ran into a few problems. First, I was open too many hours. The first child was dropped off between 5:00 and 5:30a.m. and the last one left between 6:00 and 6:45p.m. Next, I had 4 to 6 children at my daycare most of the time so I couldn’t take them anywhere. With a passenger side air bag and only 3 seats in the back, it was rare that we went on field trips. Also, because I was busy caring for the children all day long, I stayed in most weekends to clean the house.
The result of all this was that my daughter rarely left the house, and although she saw a few kids everyday, they were the same few kids each day, and they were within the confines of our home. When we would finally leave the house to go for a walk on a weekend or go to the mall, or even a family function, my daughter would be afraid of everybody. I remember many times pushing her in a stroller through the mall and people stopping to say something like, “Oh what a beautiful baby.” I dreaded this, because no sooner would the words pass their lips then my daughter would start screaming “NOOOOOOO” at the top of her lungs and hide her face in her hands. It was more than embarrassing. At family functions when an aunt, uncle, cousin, or grandparent would try to pick her up to hug and kiss her or even just try to talk to her, they would get the same screaming response.
I had to purposely take her to busy shopping centers or at least up to the store starting with once a week and working up to once a day to get her used to people. I’m not sure what would’ve happened if I didn’t purposely expose her to lots of different people everyday. But what did happen, was by 2 1/2 years old she was ready for an audience. I signed her up for dance class not sure how she’d respond to being dropped off for an hour and being left there (parents weren’t allowed to stay). So I kept telling her how she would learn a dance with a bunch of other little girls, then get a beautiful costume and perform on stage, then everyone would clap for her. The first day we walked into dance class she looked around then threw herself on the floor crying. I asked her what was wrong assuming that she was upset because she didnt’ know anyone. Her response was, “THERE ISN’T ANY STAGE!”
I think that the nature/nurture thing comes into play as well. Children are born with a personality and may be introverts or extroverts whether they are home-schooled or attend preschool and public schools. I feel that they all find their way eventually. I think some may tend to be shy or very out going but I wouldn’t be quick to point blame. Had I gone back to work and put my baby in daycare, she would probably have been used to people and interacted well without my conscious effort of bringing her out everyday and it would’ve been a lot easier on me. But, if I kept her in my house and continued with the daycare business, she would eventually have gone to school and I think she would have caught up on the socialization scale on her own after a while.
I don’t personally know anyone who has been home schooled, but from what I hear, home schooled children get their socialization piece by taking part in activities and sports, and playing with other children when those children get home from school and on weekends.
I do babysit for several different families that have full time nannies during the day. The children in these families do tend to seem more shy when they are outside of their home than the ones who have always been in daycare. One other difference that I’ve noticed is that the children cared for by a nanny all day, tend to talk more like little adults and use mannerisms and expressions that are very adult-like.
My opinion is that in the long run whether a child is introverted or extroverted has more to do with the personality the child was born with and will only vary slightly due to whether or not their socialization took place early in childhood or later. I would love to hear other people’s experiences or thoughts on this.
Lisa McLellan, Child Care Expert